Blog

From GTA 5 to GTA 6: What 13 Years Changed in SEO, Advertising and AI

Ask AI about this article:ChatGPTClaudeCopy as Markdown

Between the launch of GTA 5 (September 17, 2013) and GTA 6 (November 19, 2026), the first position in Google lost a large share of its clicks: Advanced Web Ranking measured a 31% CTR on desktop in 2014, and in September 2026 in the US, 19% without an AI Overview and 15% with one. In the Search Console data of the sites we run at VerticalSEO, the gap between branded and non-branded queries is even wider. A branded query in first place has a CTR of about 30%, and a non-branded query 3.4-4.7% (median across sites, October 2026). Below I have collected numbers from those 13 years about search, advertising, artificial intelligence and a few things outside SEO.

This article expands on my LinkedIn carousel “Grand Theft Clicks”. For numbers from other people's studies I give the year or the measurement period, and the full list of sources is at the end. My own data comes from Google Search Console for the sites we run at VerticalSEO, my agency. I do not name the sites. Prices, valuations and user numbers change from week to week, so I give them with the date I read them.

Contents
  1. What was happening in SEO when GTA 5 came out?
  2. How has first-position CTR in Google changed?
  3. How many clicks does first place bring for branded and non-branded queries?
  4. What has changed in advertising and social media?
  5. Where was artificial intelligence when GTA 5 came out?
  6. What else has changed in those 13 years?
  7. What from the 2013 internet no longer exists?
  8. What does this mean for SEO?
  9. Frequently asked questions about CTR in Google

What was happening in SEO when GTA 5 came out?

In late August and September 2013, within a single month, Google took away SEO specialists' keyword tool and query data in Analytics, and on top of that announced a new algorithm. I was an SEO specialist at the time and was just moving to an agency in Warsaw, so I remember that month well.

DateWhat happened
August 28, 2013Google shuts down the Keyword Tool in AdWords. Keyword Planner remains.
September 17, 2013GTA 5 launches on PS3 and Xbox 360.
September 23, 2013Google confirms that it encrypts all searches. Queries from Google disappear in Analytics under “(not provided)”.
September 26, 2013Google announces Hummingbird, a new algorithm that had already been running for about a month.

The two weeks before the GTA 6 launch are busy in search too. Around November 6, 2026, Google started showing ads in the US on follow-up questions in AI Mode conversations as well. On November 10, the November core update started rolling out, and it is expected to take about two weeks. On November 12, Google switched on the Gemini 4 Hydrogen model in Search. GTA 6 comes out on November 19, nine days after the core update started.

How has first-position CTR in Google changed?

In Advanced Web Ranking (AWR) measurements, the CTR of the first position in Google on desktop fell from 31% in 2014 to 19% in September 2026 on results pages without an AI Overview, and to 15% on pages with an AI Overview. The two measurements are not identical, so the comparison is approximate. The 2014 study covered desktop, the US and other markets. The September 2026 measurement covers desktop in the US and splits results into pages with and without an AI Overview. There is no AWR measurement from 2013. A Catalyst study using the same method (Webmaster Tools data, October 2012-June 2013) found 17% for the first position, but only for 59 FMCG brands, so I do not compare it with today's results. In June 2013, Chitika calculated that the first position takes 32.5% of the traffic from Google, but that is a share of traffic, not CTR. In Poland, AI Overviews have been available since March 2025, and AI Mode in Polish since October 2025.

  • 31%CTR of the first position in Google on desktop, 2014 measurement (US and other markets).Advanced Web Ranking, 2014
  • 19.35%CTR of the first position on desktop in the US when there is no AI Overview above the results.Advanced Web Ranking, Sep 2026
  • 14.78%CTR of the first position on desktop in the US when there is an AI Overview above the results.Advanced Web Ranking, Sep 2026
  • 11% vs 27%CTR of the first position in Germany with and without an AI Overview, over 100 million queries.SISTRIX, Feb 2026
  • 3.9%CTR of the first position on desktop for informational queries without an AI Overview, calculated from Search Console data (December 2025, 300,000 queries). With an AI Overview, 1.6%.Ahrefs, Feb 2026
  • 68%of Google searches in the US end without a click (Similarweb panel, desktop and mobile browsers).SparkToro and Similarweb, Jan-Apr 2026
  • 29%of the queries studied in Polish Google had an AI Overview.Senuto, Nov 2025

AWR also shows where this gap ends. According to the same measurement, beyond the third position the CTR on results pages with and without an AI Overview is almost the same, so the AI Overview takes clicks mainly from the very top of the results. Navigational queries, where someone is looking for a specific site or brand, lose the most at the first position. I explain how AI Overviews choose the pages they cite in the article on SEO for AI search.

How many clicks does first place bring for branded and non-branded queries?

On the sites we run at VerticalSEO, a query with the brand name in first place had a CTR of about 30% in October 2026, and a non-branded query 3.4-4.7%. That is several times less at the same average position. I give a range rather than a single number, because the result depends on the impressions threshold and on whether I count the largest site in the sample.

Average position in Search ConsoleBranded queryNon-branded query
128-30%3.4-4.7%
210-15%3.4-4.6%
3approx. 9-10%2.1-2.8%
4-54-6%1.2-1.3%
6-10approx. 3%0.5-0.6%

How I calculated it: I took the queries from the Performance report in Search Console for October 2026, broken down by site. The brand is the site's name with its spelling variants, matched with a regular expression. For each site I calculated the CTR in each average position bracket (row 1 is queries with an average position below 1.5, row 2 from 1.5 to 2.5, row 3 from 2.5 to 3.5, then 3.5-5.5 and 5.5-10.5), and the table shows the median across sites. A site entered a bracket if it had at least 500, 1,000 or 2,000 impressions in it; the range in the table covers the results for these three thresholds, with and without the largest site. The calculation includes only the queries the API returns, without anonymized queries. These are sites from several countries and industries, counted together for all devices, so this is not a benchmark for Poland. For branded queries the sample is small from the second position onwards and smallest at positions 4-10, so I treat those rows as approximate.

My numbers for non-branded queries are much lower than AWR's, but close to the Ahrefs measurement: 3.9% at the first position on desktop for informational queries without an AI Overview. All three measurements calculate CTR from Search Console data, but on different samples. AWR gives one result for all queries together, including navigational ones, and only for the US and desktop. My data covers only non-branded queries, with the long tail, phones and markets outside the US. The second point: in my data, a non-branded query in position 1 does not get clearly more clicks than in position 2. I do not know exactly why. One possible reason: Search Console gives all links in an AI Overview the position of the whole block. So when the AI Overview sits at the top, a citation in it counts as position 1, even though it is not the first regular result.

I ran the same calculation for October 2025, on the sites that had data for both years. The CTR of branded queries in first place was about one tenth lower in 2026 than a year earlier (median of the changes for each site between the two years, relative, not in percentage points), but from site to site the change ranged from -67% to +45%, so I do not treat it as a trend. For non-branded queries I see no consistent direction of change year on year.

What has changed in advertising and social media?

The organic reach of a Facebook page post has dropped several times over, a click on a search ad in the US costs more than twice as much, and the Polish online advertising market has grown more than fourfold. In 2026, advertising also moved into AI chats.

20132026
Organic reach of a Facebook page postapprox. 13% of fans1-2% of fans
Average cost per click on search ads, USUSD 2.32 (2015 measurement)USD 5.42
Online advertising in PolandPLN 2.4 billion (about USD 600 million at the National Bank of Poland mid rate of November 16, 2026)PLN 10.9 billion (about USD 2.7 billion) (2025)
Social media share of that budget4.9%17.1% (2025)
Google and Facebook (Meta) advertising revenueUSD 58 billionUSD 491 billion (2025)
Ads in AI chatsdid not existin ChatGPT in Poland since August 2026, not yet in Google's AI Mode in Poland

The 2015 cost per click comes from the first edition of the WordStream benchmarks; the 2026 edition covers Google Ads and Microsoft Ads, so the samples differ. Both numbers refer to search ads in the US. The 2013 Facebook reach is the median from September 2013 (EdgeRank Checker), and today's figure is the average reach relative to the number of followers in 2026 (Socialinsider), so the order of magnitude is certain, not the exact multiplier. OpenAI started testing ads in ChatGPT (Free and Go plans) in the US in February 2026, and in August 2026 extended them to Europe, including Poland. Google shows ads in AI Mode in some countries, but Poland is not on that list in November 2026.

Where was artificial intelligence when GTA 5 came out?

In 2013 there was no OpenAI or Anthropic, and DeepMind was a London startup that Google bought a few months later. Today, these companies' models answer questions that people used to take to a search engine.

20132026
OpenAIdid not exist (founded in December 2015)USD 852 billion valuation (Mar 2026)
ChatGPTdid not exist1.2 billion weekly users (Sep 2026)
Anthropicdid not exist (founded in 2021)plans to go public on November 19, 2026
DeepMindLondon startup, approx. 50-75 people, bought by Google in January 2014Gemini: over 1 billion monthly users (Oct 2026)
Nvidiaapprox. USD 9 billion in market valueapprox. USD 3.9 trillion (November 13, 2026)
Private investment in AI companies worldwideapprox. USD 6 billion a yearapprox. USD 290 billion (2025)

I give the figures for private investment in AI companies according to the AI Index and Our World in Data, in 2021 dollars. Anthropic's stock market debut is scheduled for the same day as the GTA 6 launch. According to CNBC, the share price is to be set on November 18, and trading is to start on November 19.

What else has changed in those 13 years?

Over 13 years, the phone has become the main device for going online worldwide, and a console now has 32 times more RAM. A few numbers from outside SEO, about Poland and about technology:

20132026
Console RAM512 MB (PS3, Xbox 360)16 GB (PS5)
Traffic from phones worldwide17%60%
Google's share of search in Poland97.5%89.4% (Bing 7.6%)
Home internet in Poland72% of households97% of households
Minimum wage in PolandPLN 1,600 (about USD 400)PLN 4,806 (about USD 1,200)
BLIK (Polish mobile payment system)did not exist (launched in 2015)21.9 million active users (Sep 2026)
iPhone in Poland5s: 1 GB RAM, from PLN 2,949 (about USD 740)18 Pro: 12 GB RAM, from PLN 6,299 (about USD 1,600)
BitcoinUSD 131approx. USD 66,000 (November 14, 2026)

GTA 5 sold more than USD 800 million worth on its first day. The first GTA 6 trailer, released in December 2023, was viewed 90 million times on YouTube in 24 hours, which Guinness World Records recognized as a record for a video game trailer.

What from the 2013 internet no longer exists?

Of the tools and services I used in 2013, more than a dozen no longer work. The list, roughly in order of shutdown:

  • the Keyword Tool in AdWords (August 2013);
  • Google keywords in Analytics, “(not provided)” since autumn 2013;
  • iGoogle (2013);
  • the green PageRank bar (last update in December 2013, switched off in 2016);
  • author photos in Google results (2014);
  • Yahoo Directory (2014) and DMOZ (2017);
  • text ads in Google's right-hand column (2016);
  • Google Instant (2017);
  • Klout (2018);
  • Google+ for consumers (2019);
  • Flash (2020);
  • Nasza Klasa (NK.pl, a Polish social network, 2021);
  • Alexa Rank (2022);
  • Universal Analytics (2023-2024);
  • the “Cached” link in Google results (2024);
  • GoldenLine (a Polish professional network, 2024);
  • Skype (2025).

Some survived under a new name. Google's business listing changed its name several times (Google Places, Google+ Local, Google My Business), and today it is Google Business Profile. Webmaster Tools is now Search Console, AdWords is Google Ads, and Twitter is X. GG, formerly Gadu-Gadu (a Polish instant messenger), is also still running.

What does this mean for SEO?

In my data, first place in Google today brings the highest CTR when someone is searching for you, not for a topic. For me, this is one more argument that a brand is not an add-on to SEO but its foundation. From the numbers above I draw three conclusions for day-to-day work:

  • I calculate CTR for branded and non-branded queries separately, because the average of both groups hides where the clicks really come from;
  • for traffic forecasts I do not use a CTR curve from before AI Overviews, but the Search Console data of the site in question, because traffic estimates that tools calculate using a fixed CTR curve can differ from Search Console by several times;
  • I treat demand for the brand name as a separate goal, alongside rankings for non-branded queries.

I describe how I measure brand visibility in AI answers in my article on AI visibility. I describe where I start working with Search Console data in my article on SEO strategy.

Frequently asked questions about CTR in Google

What is the CTR of the first position in Google in 2026?

According to Advanced Web Ranking, in September 2026 on desktop in the US it was about 19% without an AI Overview and about 15% with an AI Overview. In my Search Console data from October 2026, a branded query in first position had a CTR of about 30%, and a non-branded query 3.4-4.7% (median across sites). These measurements calculate CTR differently, so they should not be compared directly.

Do AI Overviews reduce CTR?

Yes, in the measurements I know, mainly in the top positions. According to AWR, in September 2026 the first position on desktop in the US had a CTR of 14.78% with an AI Overview and 19.35% without one. SISTRIX calculated 11% with an AI Overview and 27% without one in Germany (published in February 2026). Pew Research Center found in March 2025 in the US that 8% of visits to a results page with an AI summary ended with a click on a regular result, compared with 15% of visits without one.

How do you separate branded queries in Search Console?

The simplest way is the branded queries filter in the Performance report. Google announced it in November 2025 and rolled it out gradually. It only works in top-level properties with enough queries. The brand is recognized there by an AI model, so the split is sometimes wrong. The second way is a query filter with a regular expression containing the brand name and its spelling variants, followed by the same filter inverted. Test the expression on the most frequent queries in both groups, because it is easy to miss a spelling variant or catch an unrelated query.

What does “(not provided)” mean in Google Analytics?

It is the label for traffic from Google for which Analytics does not receive the query, because the search is encrypted. In autumn 2013 it applied to most of the traffic from Google's organic results, and over time to almost all of it. Today you check the queries that bring users to your site in Search Console.

External sources (checked November 14, 2026):
  • Advanced Web Ranking: Google Organic CTR Study 2014 (static.advancedwebranking.com)
  • Advanced Web Ranking: CTR Study, September 2026 (app.advancedwebranking.com)
  • Chitika: The Value of Google Result Positioning (2013) (web.archive.org)
  • PRWeb: Catalyst, Google CTR study (October 17, 2013) (prweb.com)
  • SparkToro: In 2026, less than one third of Google searches still send a click (sparktoro.com)
  • Senuto: report on AI Overviews in Poland (insight.senuto.com)
  • Google: AI Overviews in Poland (March 25, 2025) (blog.google)
  • Search Engine Roundtable: AI Mode in more languages (October 9, 2025) (seroundtable.com)
  • Search Console Help: data in the Performance report (support.google.com)
  • Google Search Central Blog: branded queries filter in Search Console (developers.google.com)
  • Ahrefs: AI Overviews reduce clicks (February 4, 2026) (ahrefs.com)
  • SISTRIX: AI Overviews in Deutschland (February 25, 2026) (sistrix.de)
  • Pew Research Center: Google users are less likely to click on links when an AI summary appears (July 22, 2025) (pewresearch.org)
  • Search Engine Roundtable: Google Keyword Tool gone (seroundtable.com)
  • Search Engine Land: Google secure searches (searchengineland.com)
  • Search Engine Land: Google Hummingbird (searchengineland.com)
  • Search Engine Land: AI Mode multi-turn ads (searchengineland.com)
  • Search Engine Land: November 2026 core update (searchengineland.com)
  • Google: Gemini 4 Hydrogen in Search (blog.google)
  • TechCrunch: The filtered feed problem (EdgeRank Checker) (techcrunch.com)
  • Socialinsider: social media reach (socialinsider.io)
  • WordStream: Google AdWords industry benchmarks (2016) (web.archive.org)
  • WordStream: Google Ads benchmarks 2026 (wordstream.com)
  • IAB AdEx 2013 (iabadex.pl)
  • IAB AdEx 2025 (iabadex.pl)
  • Google 10-K 2013 (sec.gov)
  • Alphabet 10-K 2025 (sec.gov)
  • Facebook 10-K 2013 (sec.gov)
  • Meta 10-K 2025 (sec.gov)
  • OpenAI: testing ads in ChatGPT (openai.com)
  • OpenAI: ads in ChatGPT in Europe (openai.com)
  • Google: ads in AI Mode (blog.google)
  • OpenAI: March 2026 valuation (openai.com)
  • OpenAI: DevDay 2026 (openai.com)
  • CNBC: Anthropic IPO (November 10, 2026) (cnbc.com)
  • TechCrunch: Google buys DeepMind (January 26, 2014) (techcrunch.com)
  • Alphabet: Q3 2026 results (blog.google)
  • Companies Market Cap: Nvidia (companiesmarketcap.com)
  • Our World in Data: private investment in AI (ourworldindata.org)
  • GamesBeat: GTA V sells $800M on first day (gamesbeat.com)
  • Game Developer: PS3 specifications (gamedeveloper.com)
  • BetaNews: Xbox 360 specifications (betanews.com)
  • PlayStation Blog: PS5 specifications (blog.playstation.com)
  • Rockstar Games: GTA VI release (rockstargames.com)
  • Guinness World Records: GTA VI trailer (guinnessworldrecords.com)
  • Take-Two: report of November 9, 2026 (sec.gov)
  • MacRumors: iPhone 5s (macrumors.com)
  • thinkapple.pl: iPhone 5s prices in Poland (thinkapple.pl)
  • Apple: iPhone 18 Pro (apple.com)
  • MacRumors: iPhone 18 Pro RAM (macrumors.com)
  • StatCounter: mobile and desktop (gs.statcounter.com)
  • StatCounter: search engines in Poland (gs.statcounter.com)
  • Dz.U. 2012 poz. 1026 (api.sejm.gov.pl)
  • Dz.U. 2025 poz. 1242 (api.sejm.gov.pl)
  • GUS: information society 2013 (stat.gov.pl)
  • GUS: internet use in 2026 (stat.gov.pl)
  • Telix: BLIK in Q3 2026 (telix.pl)
  • StatMuse: Bitcoin on September 17, 2013 (statmuse.com)
  • Yahoo Finance: Bitcoin (finance.yahoo.com)
  • iGoogle (seroundtable.com)
  • PageRank (seroundtable.com)
  • author photos (9to5google.com)
  • Yahoo Directory (searchengineland.com)
  • DMOZ (searchengineland.com)
  • right-hand column ads (searchengineland.com)
  • Google Instant (9to5google.com)
  • Klout (techcrunch.com)
  • Google+ (cloud.google.com)
  • Flash (adobe.com)
  • NK.pl (tvn24.pl)
  • Alexa Rank (engadget.com)
  • Universal Analytics (support.google.com)
  • “Cached” link (searchengineland.com)
  • GoldenLine (itwiz.pl)
  • Skype (techcrunch.com)
  • Google Business Profile (seroundtable.com)
  • Search Console (developers.google.com)
  • GG (antyweb.pl)

My own data: Google Search Console for the sites run at VerticalSEO, October 2025 and October 2026, queries returned by the API.